Shopify Payments alternatives: when a third-party gateway makes sense
Learn when Shopify Payments alternatives make sense, what a third-party gateway does, and how Points Business tools can support a Shopify store.
By Points for Business team · Reviewed by Preston Jones · Published · 6 min read · Drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by our team
Short answer: Shopify Payments is Shopify's built-in way to accept cards on a Shopify store. A third-party payment gateway is a separate merchant account and payment provider that can process those orders instead of, or in some cases alongside, Shopify Payments. That setup can make sense when you sell in more than one place, want payment tools that are not tied to a single storefront, or cannot use Shopify Payments for your business or location. Points Business offers a payment gateway, embedded payments, payment links, a virtual terminal, and in-person tools under one merchant account.
What is Shopify Payments, and what is a third-party gateway?
Shopify Payments is the payment provider Shopify operates for stores in supported countries and regions. Shopify describes it as a way to accept major payment methods from your Shopify admin without setting up a separate provider.
A third-party payment gateway is a provider other than Shopify Payments. Shopify documents that you can use a third-party provider as your only card provider, or, in some cases, use one alongside Shopify Payments. Shopify also distinguishes two kinds of third-party providers:
- Direct providers, where customers can finish paying on your online store.
- External providers, where customers complete payment on a checkout page hosted outside your store.
Points Business is a merchant account with online payments tools you can use for website checkout, plus payment links, a virtual terminal for phone and email orders, recurring billing, and in-person options such as a POS and Tap to Pay on a compatible Apple or Android phone or tablet. A hosted payment page can be branded with your business's look.
Points Business can take website payments through a payment gateway, a hosted checkout page, or developer tools such as API keys and webhooks. Contact Points at info@thepoints.io or (833) 374-1518 if you have questions about your account.
When does a third-party gateway make sense for a Shopify store?
Shopify Payments is a straightforward option for many stores that sell mainly through Shopify. A third-party gateway is worth a closer look when:
- You sell in more than one channel. If you take cards in person, send invoices, or sell from a site that is not your Shopify checkout, one merchant account can cover those payments alongside your online store.
- You want tools that live with your merchant account. Payment links, a virtual terminal, recurring billing, embedded payments, and Tap to Pay can be useful when sales happen off the Shopify checkout, such as phone orders, deposits, or pop-up events.
- You want a merchant account that is not tied to one platform. If you might add another storefront later, or move off Shopify, a third-party merchant account can stay with the business.
- Shopify Payments is not available for your business or location. Shopify Payments is only offered in certain countries and regions, and not every business can use it. In those cases Shopify directs merchants to a third-party provider that supports their business type.
A third-party gateway is not automatically the better choice. If your sales happen only on Shopify and Shopify Payments is available to you, it may already cover what you need.
What should you check before you change payment providers on Shopify?
Before you replace or add a provider, review Shopify's current requirements for your store. A few points from Shopify's own documentation are easy to miss:
- US sales tax settings. If your store is based in the United States and Shopify manages your US sales tax, Shopify does not allow third-party payment providers until you set US sales tax to self-directed. Confirm this in your Shopify admin, or with Shopify Support, before you change providers.
- Checkout features you rely on. Some Shopify checkout features, such as Shop Pay, are built to work with Shopify Payments. If those features matter to your checkout, confirm with Shopify what you will still be able to offer after a change.
- How customers will pay. A direct provider keeps checkout on your store. An external provider sends the customer to a hosted payment page. Neither is wrong; it is a question of the experience you want and what your provider supports.
- Your other sales channels. If you already accept cards in person or by invoice, look at whether the same merchant account can cover those payments so you are not reconciling two providers.
You can activate or change a payment provider from the Payments page in your Shopify admin. Review Shopify's current provider requirements for your store before you make a change.
How can Points Business help if you sell on Shopify and in other channels?
Points Business is built for online stores as well as retail, restaurants, salons, home services, and professional services. You apply once and add the payment tools that fit your business. For an ecommerce or Shopify merchant, those tools typically include:
| Tool | How it can help |
|---|---|
| Payment gateway | Accept card payments from a website checkout under your Points merchant account. |
| Embedded payments | Take card payments inside your own site or checkout experience, with fewer handoffs to a separate page. |
| Hosted checkout | Send customers to a secure hosted payment page, which you can brand with your business's look. |
| Payment links | Share a secure URL by text or email when a customer owes a specific amount, including deposits and invoices. |
| Virtual terminal | Key in a card payment for an order you take by phone or email. |
| Recurring billing | Collect repeat payments for subscriptions or memberships. |
| POS and Tap to Pay | Take in-person card payments at a counter, on the go, or on a compatible phone or tablet, with no extra hardware for Tap to Pay. |
All of these are live Points Business products, managed from the merchant dashboard. Loyalty is coming soon.
If you already process payments with another provider, you can share a recent statement and the Points team will walk you through a side-by-side comparison of your existing arrangement. Savings are not guaranteed and depend on your business, volume, and approval.
Website checkout with Points Business uses a payment gateway, a hosted checkout page you can brand, or developer tools such as API keys and webhooks. Contact support before you start so we can confirm what your account supports.
If you are ready to talk through the options, Sign up for a Merchant Account or email info@thepoints.io. You can also call (833) 374-1518, 24/7.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to leave Shopify to use a third-party payment gateway?
No. Shopify allows third-party payment providers on stores that meet its requirements. You can keep selling on Shopify and process cards through a provider other than Shopify Payments. Some stores also use a third-party provider alongside Shopify Payments. Check Shopify's current rules for your country, business type, and tax settings first.
How can I use Points Business with a Shopify store?
Points Business provides a payment gateway, a hosted checkout page you can brand, and developer tools such as API keys and webhooks. How those tools fit a particular store depends on that store's setup and on Shopify's current provider rules. Contact the Points team at info@thepoints.io or (833) 374-1518 with questions about your account before you change anything in Shopify.
Will I lose Shop Pay or other Shopify checkout features?
Some Shopify checkout features, including Shop Pay, are designed to work with Shopify Payments. If you rely on those features, confirm with Shopify what will still be available if you add or switch to a third-party provider. Do not assume every checkout option will carry over.
What if Shopify Payments is not available for my business?
Shopify Payments is limited to certain countries and regions, and it is not offered for every type of business. If you cannot use it, Shopify's documentation points merchants to a third-party payment provider that supports their business type. A Points merchant account can be a fit when you also need payment links, a virtual terminal, or in-person tools. Review Shopify's current provider rules for your store before you change payment providers.
How do I compare my current processing to Points Business?
Share a recent statement and the Points team will walk you through a side-by-side comparison of your existing payment processing arrangement. You can start that process at the assessment page. Results depend on your business, volume, and approval.
Sources
Ready to take payments with Points Business?
Create your merchant account, or send us a recent processing statement and a specialist will walk through it with you.